How to Improve Customer Retention Among First-Time Holiday Shoppers

As retailers prepare for another rollercoaster of a holiday season, they have a lot to look forward to. After 2021 saw a 17-year high of holiday shoppers spending 8.5 percent more year over year (YOY), forecasters predict continued growth despite the threat of a recession and looming inflation on the horizon. In fact, experts believe that retail shopping will rise again in 2022, between four and six percent. This means an influx of new holiday shoppers to attract, delight, and retain. In the spirit of looking forward to another successful year, these post-holiday marketing best practices explore how to improve customer retention among new shoppers, so you can increase revenue not just for the season at hand, but also for the year ahead. 

1. Dress Your Goods to Impress Recipients and Holiday Shoppers Alike

Holiday shoppers who are sending gifts to far-flung friends and family members appreciate an unboxing experience that mirrors the magic of receiving a beautifully-wrapped gift in person —and so do their recipients.

The investment you make in a memorable unboxing experience can benefit your business in two ways:

  • The gift buyer and recipient will consider sending more of your products to family and friends as gifts due to their elevated presentation
  • The gift recipient might share your products displayed with packaging and extras on social media, creating a DIY advertisement for your business

If you haven’t yet tried to bolster your packaging with branded touches, take some lessons from DTC beauty brand Dip with these five unboxing tips

2. Give Your Post-Purchase Email Welcome Series a Holiday Update

Add a new branch to your post-purchase email welcome series that is solely dedicated to retaining holiday shoppers. This enables your marketing team to optimize onboarding emails by determining what the customers who recently discovered your brand and products care about most. In addition to a confirmation email, request for a review, and other staple follow-ups, consider including:
A product quiz that reveals what the buyer likes
Many holiday shoppers are on your site to buy gifts for others, so their purchase may not necessarily reflect their interests or potential future purchases. Send a short quiz in your post-purchase email series that asks them about their preferences. 
Let’s say you’re a DTC skincare brand, you can ask your customer about:
  • Their skin type
  • Skin challenges and goals
  • Favorite fragrances

Once they complete it, you can set up your marketing automation system to tag them by their answers and segment the content you send to them accordingly so outreach from your brand is much more likely to be relevant and resonant. 

An update on popular items that were recently restocked 
With supply chain issues still in effect, not every customer will get their hands on the season’s hot ticket items in time for the holidays. But that doesn’t mean they won’t want to score the latest trends when they’re back in stock. Send an email with a curation of your most popular items that are newly available to leverage their buzz beyond the major shopping days.
A price-drop notification email on items shoppers engaged with but didn’t purchase
Lean on dynamic content to automate price-drop emails to first-time customers that lets them know that items they were eyeing are now on sale. Due to inflation, customers are most enticed by getting the best price, so even though the season is over, they may still take the plunge if the offer is too good to pass up. 

3. Pinpoint Your Top Holiday Sale and Launch a Post-Holiday Version

While you don’t want to focus on sale after sale especially after the slew of holiday promotions, strategically choosing a single sale to entice first-time shoppers to buy once again can jumpstart your retention efforts. First, decide what your goal is for this sale. Would you like to boost overall revenue, the number of conversions, average purchase value, or average items per order? 

Dive into your data to determine which holiday sale drove the most success for the metric you aim to improve and create a post-holiday sale that mirrors its promotion.  For example, if your goal is to increase average purchase value by the end of the year, determine which sale achieved the highest average purchase value during the holiday season. Let’s say that sale was “Save $50 when you spend $200.” You may want to repeat this sale structure in a way that aligns with the week after the holiday like framing it as a holiday clearance sale. 

4. Tout the Benefits of Your Customer Loyalty Program to Holiday Shoppers

Fifty-three percent of consumers say that they joined at least one or more brand or retailer’s loyalty program, so introducing new customers to its benefits soon after their first purchase is a good idea if you want to keep them coming back. 
As mentioned before, customer retention success is often achieved by listening to what first-time customers tell you through their purchase behaviors and engagement data. The good news is that first-party data is even easier to obtain when you have loyalty benefits to give them in exchange.

80 percent of customers say they are are willing to share personal data to earn loyalty program benefits, and 70 percent are willing to share their data to get special discounts and offers.

To make sure first-time customers don’t miss out on the opportunity to join your loyalty program, be sure to promote it through banners on your website, in your post-purchase emails, and on your website’s check out page by giving them the option to earn points with their purchase. 
If you don’t have a loyalty program, you’ll first want to decide how to structure it. You could opt for one or a mix of the following models:

5. Boost Customer Retention With Convenient Ways to Stay In Touch

  • Not every holiday shopper will be glued to their inbox after the season’s end. Impending credit card bills and email fatigue may cause them to avoid the Promotions tab altogether. In order to keep lines of communication open, promote different ways to stay on their radar that don’t rely on email click-throughs like:
    • Inviting them to follow your brand on social media
    • Asking customers to opt-in for text messages 
    • Including thank you post-cards with promo codes and social media handles in holiday shipments

You may also like...

Subscribe to Our Blog

Subscribe to receive an email when we publish new content!

    Ready To Empower Your Business?

    We can help you future-ready your business with customized, innovative solutions designed to foster sustainable growth.



    Meto is a tech-based nonprofit intent on making access to quality higher education a reality for all students. We have a special focus on creating scholarships for low-income students.

    In 2018, Meto was founded to connect African students with university opportunities. Along the way, we have learned that all students can benefit from our innovative model, wherein universities make the first move and invite good-fit students to apply. So, in 2023, we opened our platform to students across the globe.


              Nikhil Badlani Foundation

              The Mission of the Nikhil Badlani Foundation (the “Foundation”) is to enhance the lives of underserved children in West Orange, NJ and neighboring communities through music lessons, scholarships, and traffic safety education for all.

              Since the Foundation was established in 2011, Theorem has consistently been an annual sponsor of and team participant in the STOP for Nikhil 5K Run/3K Walk. This event intends to raise traffic safety awareness and to serve as a way to remembervbgfc ≈ and honor those who have been killed or seriously injured in traffic accidents. We recognize the importance of raising awareness and road safety amongst teenagers and parents alike, especially in the local communities of our Chatham, New Jersey office. Learn more about the Nikhil Badlani Foundation at

              Diversity and Inclusion

              Theorem actively aids in the ongoing fight against systemic racism and discrimination, realizing the importance of ongoing discussions surrounding diversity and inclusion.

              By contributing to organizations such as Black Girls Code and the Anti-Racism fund, we aim to be a fundamental supporter of diversity in the workplace and beyond. These organizations specifically speak to Theorem’s role as a leading voice in the technology innovation space and we avidly support their missions. The vision of Black Girls Code is to empower girls of color, ages 7-17 to become innovators in STEM fields and encourages them to be the builders of their own futures. The Anti-Racism Fund serves as a response to the inequities experienced by the African-American community. It provides monetary support to a dynamic portfolio of curated organizations as a way to inject and enable social change.

              Feeding America

              Feeding America is the largest charity working to end hunger in the United States. By partnering with local food banks, food pantries and other community food programs, Feeding America looks to advance change across the country and ensure equitable access to nutritious food.

              As a long-standing contributor and sponsor of Feeding America, we deeply believe in their vision of an America without hunger. The need for and importance of organizations like Feeding America has has become more and more prevalent as communities face more hardships as a result of the pandemic and the current economy. Theorem is dedicated to its continued contributions to Feeding America to do our part to empower and strengthen our communities. Learn more about Feeding America at

              Grameen America

              Grameen America is dedicated to helping entrepreneurial women who live in poverty build businesses to enable financial stability mobility.

              Since their founding in the United States in 2008, Theorem has supported Grameen America’s mission, which seeks to build upon the legacy of Presidential Medal of Freedom, Congressional Gold Medal and Nobel Peace Prize winner Muhammad Yunus. Through financial contributions and event participation, Theorem has contributed to Grameen America’s cause. As an immigrant entrepreneur himself, our CEO Jay Kulkarni is especially eager to support the organization’s mission of aiding underserved communities. Learn more about Grameen America at

              Vision Spring

              VisionSpring is making the wonder of clear vision possible for all by helping provide affordable and quality eyeglasses to those in need. For many, lack of access to affordable eyeglasses leads to loss of employment or less educational opportunities.

              VisionSpring partners with organizations who join them in their mission of supporting livelihood initiatives, enhancing potential for all. Learn more about Vision Spring at Theorem has consistently partnered with VisionSpring to organize free events, such as eye check-ups, across multiple villages in the Mysuru, India region, impacting over 3,000 rural residents. We stand with VisionSpring in their mission to increase accessibility to quality eyewear and eye care.

              Covenant House

              Covenant House provides housing and supportive services to youth facing homelessness, helping young people transform their lives.

              For more than 5+ years, Theorem has supported Covenant House with corporate sponsorships, leading career-building workshops at their Newark, NJ shelter facility and participation in the organization’s fund raising Sleep Outs. Covenant House utilizes these Sleep Outs to raise funds and help shine a light on the injustice of youth homelessness, inspiring communities to step up and protect the vulnerable. We are proud to support Covenant House’s programs, which are designed to empower young people to overcome and rise above adversity, today and in the future. Learn more about Covenant House at

              Contract Type



              Job Title

              Contract Type



              Job Title

              Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.